Ilia Pim
It's done, It's been done or it was done? Is it grammatically correct to say it's done or it's finished when we have the completed action/work. For example "Have you finished your work?". "Yes, it's done." or "Yes, it is finished" If it is correct I don't really get why because of the passive voice rules saying that you should use is/are when the action is still happening and was/were, when the action was completed.
26. Sep. 2022 20:25
Antworten · 9
3
It's one of those examples wherein language is not a set of prescribed grammatically correct rules. Yes, formal rules of grammar incorporate past perfect, present perfect, and on and on it goes; in that regard, you are correct. But, colloquial usages mix and match words and bypass strict rules. Those who have mastered a language can play with the language. So . . . Yes, it's common to hear. Closer to home example: Person 1: "You finished?" Person 2: "Yep, all done!"
26. September 2022
2
In "it's done" and "it's finished", the past participles are used as predicate adjectives; it's not the passive voice. We know this only by the context. In this situation, the passive voice would be "it's been done / finished", but that would imply that someone else did the work (or else we would just answer "yes, I have").
2. Oktober 2022
1
This is a great question. In the case of “it’s done”, I think done is acting as an adjective. We’re using the present to show it was done (ack) recently. I also agree with the person who said, when in doubt, you can answer using the same grammar as the question. https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/english/done_1
28. September 2022
Hmm.. I would respond to 'Have you finished your work?' with 'Yeah, I have' or 'Yeah, I've finished my work'. I would reply 'It's done' if someone asked me 'Is your work done?', and 'It's finished' if someone asked me 'Is your work finished?'. So I guess the response kind of correlates to the way the question was asked?
26. September 2022
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!