joggingMulberry
How old did you say you are/were? A: How old are you? B: I am 31 C: Sorry, I didn't hear you clearly. How old did you say you are/were? The book I am reading says 'were' is correct, because a sub-clause (that you are/were 31 years old) should follow the same tense as the main clause (you said). However, I doubt it because it doesn't make sense to me. I have already asked a question on this, but I just want to confirm here. 'are' is the correct word to use, right? Thanks in advance!
20. Jan. 2014 16:26
Antworten · 4
3
Hi joggingMulberry - Both are correct. The book is giving you a general rule for reporting verbs, but If we are reporting a fact or something that is still true, the direct speech form can be used. Hope this helps. Rachel.
20. Januar 2014
1
Were is the correct answer. The verb tense in this particular sentence must match. How old did (past) you say you are (present)/ were (past)? As you can see both verbs talked about the past. 31 being the age is irrelevant. The question is asking what he/she said the age was. In colloquial speech, I doubt anyone would know the difference.
20. Januar 2014
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!