Natalia
"Needn't have done" or "didn't have to do" Hello! I came across an exercise that requires to fill in the gap, choosing between "didn't need to bring " and "needn't have brought" in the following statement: "You _______________ the coursebook with you. That was the reason why the teacher yelled at you". According to the keys, the correct answer is "needn't have brought". The following explanation is given to clarify the choice: "When something was not necessary, but you did it, you can use either needn’t have + past participle or didn’t need to + infinitive: We needn’t have booked/didn’t need to book. The restaurant is empty!" IMHO the explanation has nothing to do with the task. Hence... questions. Is it possible to use "didn't need to bring" in this situation (my guess is "not"?) If not, why do we choose "needn't have brought"? Thank you!
26. Nov. 2019 19:28
Antworten · 5
2
"Didn't have to do" is more common than "needn't have done" in modern English. The topic came up in a recent discussion. https://www.italki.com/question/465160 Here are some comments by Su.Ki., a respected italki member. 'Need' is what we call a 'semi-modal'. This means that it sometimes works like a modal verb ( like 'must', 'can', 'may' 'will') and it sometimes works like a normal kind of verb ( like 'want'). Modal verbs form questions by inversion, negatives by simply adding 'not' or 'nt' and are followed by the bare infinitive. When 'need' is in its modal form, the question is 'Need I go?' and the negative is 'I needn't go'. Ordinary verbs form questions and negatives with 'do' in simple tenses and are followed by 'to' before the infinitive. When 'need' is in its (let's call it) 'ordinary verb' form, the question is 'Do I need to go?' and the negative is 'I don't need to go'. There is rarely any difference in meaning between the two forms. The modal form, 'needn't', is quite formal and old-fashioned. It is much more unusual than the more regular form, 'don't need to', and also much less useful. I wouldn't worry about trying to use 'needn't, if I were you.
26. November 2019
Thank you, Angela! I hope that teachers only do it grammar coursebooks :)
27. November 2019
Either one is fine. If I heard "needn't have brought" I would assume the person speaking was British; I wouldn't think they were _ungrammatical_. Also, teachers shouldn't yell at you for bringing an unnecessary textbook. That seems unwarranted.
26. November 2019
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!