Nana
Could you check these sentences please? I fell asleep while reading a book. I fell asleep over my book. I fell asleep over reading a book. I fell asleep with reading a book. Are they all the correct way to say?
Mar 14, 2013 6:32 AM
Answers · 8
2
I fell asleep while reading a book. <-- correct, very natural I fell asleep over my book. <-- wrong "over" means "above" and you can't fall asleep above a book. Instead, you would use "on top of" meaning your head was on top of the book, touching the book as you slept. I fell asleep on top of my book. <-- correct I fell asleep over reading a book. <-- wrong I fell asleep with reading a book. <-- wrong
March 14, 2013
1
You set the context in your first sentence. While reading a book, you fall asleep. In that context, only the first sentence is natural. However if the context had been. "I woke up and felt something hard under me", you could say "It appeared that I fell asleep on top of my book". Otherwiseto answer your question, all the othe sentences are somewhat unusual
March 17, 2013
Actually over reading my book is a little unusual, but over can be used in a similar way. The child was so sleepy, they fell asleep over dinner. , Here "over" means "during".
March 14, 2013
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!