liveoutmyway
Is "the verb -ing form after SPEND" a gerund or a present participle(as adjective)? Is "the verb -ing form after SPEND" a gerund or a present participle(as adjective)? 1 the website says "the verb -ing form after SPEND" = gerund They spend their time reading. source: https://www.englisch-hilfen.de/en/grammar/gerund.htm Another website says there is preposition(In) omitted here, so the "reading" should be a gerund like, "They spend their time (in) reading." 2. But the other website says "the verb -ing form after SPEND" = present participle =adjective) with the verbs spend and waste The inefficient blogger spent her entire afternoon researching and writing one post. (modify the subject “blogger”) source: https://www.dailywritingtips.com/present-participle-as-adjective/ which one is correct? I would really appreciate it, If it interesting you to help correct any mistake I make.
Aug 26, 2019 9:11 AM
Answers · 4
#1 is the common answer. Grammar books and websites usually list "spend time verb-ing" in their explanation of gerunds. Some grammar books avoid the discussion of gerunds and participles by just refering to verb-ing. Some linguists combine gerunds and participles into "gerund-participle" saying that there is no important difference. #2 The inefficient blogger spent her entire afternoon researching and writing one post. (modify the subject “blogger”) I disagree with the writer's explanation that the phrase "researching and writing one post" modifies the subject blogger. As written, the phrase modifies the verb spent and functions as an adverbial phrase. (How did she spend the afternoon? She spent the afternoon researching and writing one post.) My preference is to analyze this as a gerund phase which is the object of the optional preposition in. The inefficient blogger spent her entire afternoon (IN) researching and writing one post. The inefficient blogger / = noun phrase - subject / spent / = verb / her entire afternoon / = noun phrase - direct object / (in) researching and writing one poast / = prepositional phrase - adverbial phrase modifying "spent" / in / preposition / researching and writing one post / = gerund phrase (gerunds and gerund object) - object of preposition "in"/
August 26, 2019
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!