Shana
How to understand the "as" in this sentence? Can I replace it with "when"? If the thought of having your partner nearby as you try to doze off, fills you with dread, you aren't alone. At first, I couldn't understand the meaning until I followed the translation. It comes very clear to me if it was written "If the thought of having your partner nearby fills you with dread when you try to doze off, you aren't alone. " It's this a normal order to put "as" in that place?
21 de jun. de 2022 7:57
Respuestas · 8
1
‘As’ has multiple meanings. It can be used for stuff like comparisons, but also has this meaning related to time. In this context, it means “while this is happening”, so it gives a sense of continuation to the relevant action. ‘When’, on the other hand, tends to be more instantaneous. In “when you doze off”, dozing off is conceptualized as a binary state. Resulting from the moment you fall asleep, something else then happens. In “as you doze off”, dozing off is conceptualized as a gradual process, during which something else also gradually happens.
21 de junio de 2022
1
Yes. This is one of the meanings of 'as'. This is from Macmillan.
21 de junio de 2022
Yes, this is very common. You can use "as", "when" or "while" as synonyms in the example you give. They can all have the meaning of "during the time that". Be careful though because there are plenty of cases where you can't just substitute these three words, one for another. In general though, "as" can always be used when there are two events happening at the same time.
21 de junio de 2022
¿No has encontrado las respuestas?
¡Escribe tus preguntas y deja que los hablantes nativos te ayuden!