ㅊㅔㄹ
ㄴ가요 vs ㄴ건가요 vs 나요 Sometimes I can understand the difference but I just was just wondering if there’s an actual grammar rule for it. What would the difference be? Are there certain situations where they are each used more? 맞는가요 vs 맞는건가요 vs 맞나요 예문으로 설명해 주시면 감사하겠습니다
29 de may. de 2020 0:20
Respuestas · 2
1
I would say -ㄴ가요 and -나요 have the same meaning and function (any difference is too subtle to mention), but there are certain contexts where one fits better than the other. -나요 seems to work with verbs better (i.e. sounds clearer and smoother, often with fewer syllables), for example, while -ㄴ가요 works well with adjectives. e.g. * (Verb) "그 사람들(은) 갔나요?" 갔는가요? is longer and slightly clunky. * (V) "아버지는 언제 돌아오시나요?" Again, 돌아오시는가요? is longer. * (Adjective) 춘천은 서울에서 얼마나 먼가요 / 머나요? Both are fine, but I would prefer 먼가요. * (A) 제주도는 어떤 곳인가요? Again, probably better than 곳이나요?. -ㄴ 건가요 is -ㄴ 것이다 connected with the -ㄴ가요? (-ㄴ 것인가요? shortens to -ㄴ 건가요?). So the difference between -ㄴ가요 and -ㄴ 건가요 is that between the direct statement X-이다 and the indirect statement X-인 것이다. -나요 can also connect to -ㄴ 것이다 to form -ㄴ 거나요? (-ㄴ 것이나요 contracts to -ㄴ 거나요?), but 거나요 sounds to me not as natural as -ㄴ 건가요. Since 이다 in 것이다 is like an adjective, this agrees with -ㄴ가요 working well with adjectives. * 이렇게 하면 되나요? => better than 되는가요? * 이렇게 하면 되는 건가요? => better than 되는 거나요?
29 de mayo de 2020
¿No has encontrado las respuestas?
¡Escribe tus preguntas y deja que los hablantes nativos te ayuden!