Júlia
What's the difference between "I HAD the windows cleaned" And "I GOT the necklace made" When can i use HAD or GOT in situations like that?
2023년 11월 21일 오후 8:40
답변 · 8
2
There's no difference in meaning, but it's usually more informal to say you "got" something done than to say you "had" something done. Sometimes one or the other is more commonly used to describe specific actions, but it would never be incorrect to use the less common one. Most people would say they "got" their hair cut; but if you said you "had" your hair cut, everyone would know what you mean.
2023년 11월 21일
1
The difference is that the first sentence is a respectable one, whereas the second sentence is a lazy one. The verb "get" means almost whatever the speaker wants it to mean. In this case "got" means "had", because that is what the speaker wants it to mean. The lesson of the story is: Be clear, don't rely on the verb "to get".
2023년 11월 22일
1
Note that ‘had’ is more precise if you are talking about someone else doing it. Example of ‘get’ with a different meaning: A: What have you accomplished this evening? B: I got my history homework done. Here we’d assume that B did his own homework. B could have alternatively said ‘I finished my history homework’ or simply ‘I did my history homework’ but ‘getting something done’ is common and understood.
2023년 11월 22일
1
Jonathan is right. I have a hard time explaining the difference to my students. Got, in my felling, is more British than had, too. Just a thought!
2023년 11월 22일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!