Oleh
Have you ever... Have you ever been to France? 1) Yes, I was there last summer or 2) Yes, I had been there last summer? explain to me pls
2013년 7월 18일 오후 5:54
답변 · 5
5
"I was there last summer" is the correct answer. We introduce an experience using present perfect, them move to past simple to give more details. We only use present perfect if there is a background to the story.
2013년 7월 18일
2
The second sentence isn't wrong, but it means something different to what you're trying to say. "I have been to France" means that at any time before now, I was in France. "I had been last France" means that at any time before last summer, I was in France ie. last summer you could have said "I have been to France". It's much more natural to say "I had been in France BY last summer."
2013년 7월 18일
2
"I was there last summer" is the correct answer because you use the past simple with a past time expression "last summer"
2013년 7월 18일
1
Just as a side note...you could also have said: "Yes, I have been there. I went there last summer."
2013년 7월 18일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!