Ana Pau
Adverbials- What is a subjunct? I need to know how subjuncts function within clause structure and how I can differenciate them from adjuncts. Thanks
2015년 2월 8일 오후 3:52
답변 · 7
1
I hope Daniele has given you what you need. I must say, unless your are studying English grammar in excruciating detail, you will never need to know these terms. Whether they are helpful to learning how to speak and write is a question for you and your teacher, I guess. I'm a pretty well educated US native who was never taught these terms, nor heard anyone use them, even in a grammar discussion.
2015년 2월 8일
I was actually guessing how relevant this thread might be for native speakers... However, it's pretty fascinating, so I kept googling. I found something clearer in this page: http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/adverbs.htm According to it, in the sentence: "The weather here is too hot." -> too much hot! "too" is an adjunct, whereas in: "The weather here is hot, too" -> not only there but also here "too" is a subjunct. Adjuncts directly modify verbs or adjectives, whereas subjuncts modify the sentence as a whole.
2015년 2월 8일
That question has bothered me too, so I did a quick search to find something that appears to be clear here: http://flesl.net/Grammar/Grammar_Glossary/subjunct.php Here you go: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ subjuncts differentiates them sharply from adjuncts. One aspect of this difference is the fact that they cannot generally be the focus of certain grammatical operations. For example, adjuncts such as “happily” or “sadly” can be contrasted with one another in “alternative interrogation” in questions such as “Did Harry smile happily or sadly when Jill told him she loved him?” but if an attempt is made to contrast subjuncts in this way as in “Does Jill deeply or slightly love Harry?” the results are unacceptable. • It is often possible for the same word to act as a subjunct in one context but not in another. • For example, in the sentence, “Sadly, Sara packed her clothes and left the next morning,” the adverb sadly is acting a subjunct. However, in the sentence, “Later, Sara spoke sadly about those terrible days,” it is an adjunct, and in “Sadly, Sarah never learnt the real truth,” it is a disjunct. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ...after reading it 10 times... I think it's impossible. Seriously, I think that it is mainly a matter of word order. For example, in the sentence: "Seriously, I think it is maily a matter of word order." "seriously" should be a subjunct, whereas in: "I was speaking seriously." "seriously" should be an adjunct. In fact, you can ask: "are you speaking seriously or ironically?" You could even forcibly contrast two subjuncts: "Seriously or ironically, do you think it is mainly a matter of word order?" But as you see, they don't really become part of the question. I think that's because "they are not as “central” to clause structure as, for example, adjunct adverbials are". I think I need an aspirin... :)
2015년 2월 8일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!