minhthi1810
Is this sentence grammatically correct: "After having taken her to the park, I went home." Thank you very much!
2016년 5월 12일 오후 4:41
답변 · 8
3
I would say more simply, "After taking her to the park, I went home."
2016년 5월 12일
It's grammatically correct, but it's redundant: the time of "having taken" is already after the time of taking, so you are talking about a time after that again, with no reference to the intermediate time. So why not just say "Having taken her ..." or "After I took her ...", or if you like, "After taking her ..."?
2016년 5월 12일
I agree with Stephanie. After having + past participle may be acceptable but it really sounds formal and a bit clumsy. I don't recommend it. The other acceptable option is : "Having taken her, ..."
2016년 5월 12일
I would say "After taking her to the park, I went home" but both are fine.
2016년 5월 12일
It sounds very natural and not too formal to my US native ear.
2016년 5월 12일
더 보기
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!