HKK
A and B is/are ? I saw some examples on grammar book like: 1.Is bread and butter good for Ted? 2.Time and tide waits for no one. The book says that 「A and B」should be seen as one, so the verb should be singular form, but Grammarly(auto grammar error highlighting plugin) shows errors about there two singular form verbs above. Can anyone explain how to determine to see 「A and B」 as one or not? Thanks!
2019년 5월 25일 오전 10:43
답변 · 6
2
In these examples your grammarly plugin is wrong and your grammar book is correct. 'bread and butter' is heard so often it is viewed as one idea and thus requiring a singular verb. Similarly, 'time and tide' requires a singular verb because the two words again represent one concept or saying.
2019년 5월 25일
1
Oo, this is hard. Because while I think "Is bread and butter good for Ted" is correct, I think "Are bread and butter good for Ted" is correct too. The most normal use of [singular to be] + [A and B] in a sentence would be "Is copying and pasting acceptable". Testing Grammarly, it also doesn't recognise the English subjunctive mood either. It's limited to the most normal forms of the English language and so it can't handle the more poetic and situational things. Don't worry too much about it though. [singular to be] + [A and B] is rather obscure in English and I can't think of any clear rules for it.
2019년 5월 25일
Thanks for sharing great information!
2019년 5월 26일
This is a reasonable area of debate. The A _ B concept can work in some contexts. It depends on whether the two nouns represent two separate conceptual objects, or are seen as one collective object .... "the hammer and sickle was the symbol of the Soviet Union", for example. Have a look at >>> https://www.quickanddirtytips.com/education/grammar/compound-subjects >>>> https://ell.stackexchange.com/questions/22791/can-every-a-or-b-plus-singular-form-of-verb-be-possible and >>>> https://ell.stackexchange.com/questions/22791/can-every-a-or-b-plus-singular-form-of-verb-be-possible >>>> https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/time-and-tide-wait-for-no-one.html
2019년 5월 25일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!