dolco
She’s very tall, as is her mother. => what's the subject of 'is'? Was it actually "She’s very tall, as she is her mother." expanded? if so, could this below have the same structure as the one in the title? "a figure they saw as having been close to the government " Like, "a figure they saw as the figure having been close to the government "
2020년 6월 14일 오후 5:13
답변 · 6
1
"Her mother" is the subject. We use inversion with "as" in this sense, or we could say (with the same meaning), "She is tall, and her mother is too." This is absolutely *not* the same meaning as "she is as tall as her mother (is)."
2020년 6월 14일
The subject of “is” is “her mother.” A better expansion of the sentence will help you see why: “She’s very tall, just like her mother is very tall.” Here, “As” = “just like”. Your sentences about the figure use “as” in a different way. Here, “they saw as” = “they believed to be”.
2020년 6월 14일
Hello! The first sentence is correct: "She's very tall, as is her mother". "as is" means "just like". So the sentence could be written like this: "She is tall, just like her mother". The sentence "a figure they saw as having been close to the government" expanded would be written like this: "a figure that they thought was close to the government before". The two sentences don't have the same structure - in the first sentence "as is" is in the present tense and in the second sentence "having been" is the past participle form of "have been". I hope that helps!
2020년 6월 14일
Well, I should say even the first sentence doesn’t make sense to me! It should be “she takes after her mother”
2020년 6월 14일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!