Sakura Suki
Does he have a good job? .... should I answer with: yes he does or yes he has! and why?
2010년 7월 5일 오후 2:07
답변 · 9
4
"Yes, he does". If you want to give a short simple answer, you have to respect the sentence structure of the question. Q: Does he...? A: Yes, he does/No, he doesn't. Replying "Yes, he has." can be confusing. The only way it can make sense to reply with "Yes, he has" is if you specify what he has. Q: Does he have a good job? A: Yes, he has a good job. (Correct) NOT A: Yes, he has. (incorrect and confusing)
2010년 7월 5일
3
Does he have a good job? You can say: - yes, he does (short variant of answer) - yes, he has a good job Look at another example: Do you speak French? - yes, I do - yes, I speak French Do you have a pen? -yes, I do -yes, I have a pen
2010년 7월 5일
2
A little bit of extra information... First, Nicolas and Marsokot gave great explanations. Sanja's answer is wrong - perhaps she is confusing "Yes, he has" with "yes, he had (a good job)". I wanted to add that you can also use "do / does" with "have / has" in a way that adds emphasis. For example: Q: Does he have a good job? A: Yes, he does. A: Yes, he has a good job. A: Yes, he does have a good job! ("does" gives emphasis here, and we switch back to "have" in place of "has"). Then you could say, "And I'm so happy about it! He was unemployed for six months, and he had no money to buy food, but now everything is much better!" Q: Do you speak French? A: Yes, I do. A: Yes, I speak French. A: Yes, I do speak French! (emphasis) Then you might say, "That's really weird that you asked, because I've been looking for someone with whom I can speak French!" Q: Do you have a pen? A: Yes, I do. A: Yes, I have a pen. A: Yes, I do have a pen! (emphasis) Then, you might say, "That is so strange, because I usually never carry a pen with me"
2010년 7월 5일
1
hi 樱,my answer is: Yes,he does! Did you meet your friend last night?? No.I didn't.
2010년 7월 5일
YES I HAVE A JOB . IM A WAITERAT A RESTAURANT
2019년 12월 22일
더 보기
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!