Caxio
Hello everyone of good masters,please helps . 1a. Even a poet, if he happens to be something else, which he must be in these days to live, may carry a dispatch-case. 1b. Even as a poet, if he happens to be something else, which he must be in these days to live, he may carry a dispatch-case. Query: Which is grammatically correct? Do both have the same meaning? 2. The country village and the urban housing estate both need the very best men which can be found for them.(original) Question: Is the original grammatically correct? What/who does the relative pronoun "which" refer to? and the pronoun "them"? I slightly guess : them ≠ the men in the original, but I don't know who are them. Are they the people who can find "the best men" in the original?
11 okt. 2024 08:49
Antwoorden · 2
I a. and b. are both correct, I think, but they are confusing. They could probably be improved by changing the order of the phrases, and or adding additional punctuation. Ex: If he happens to be something else (which he must be these days to live), even a poet may carry a briefcase. In 2. I'm pretty sure it should be THAT instead of WHICH, but it's impossible to say for sure, as we don't know the original intent. Google 'that vs which' and you'll get the idea.
12 okt. 2024 06:00
Genodigde
To me it feels like both under 1 could be correct. Their meanings are different. 1a feels like the poet in question is a random poet (any poet). So, the 'he' in the if-clause refers to any poet as well. In '1b' it feels like the 'he' is a specific person and 'poet' is not a person but an occupation. It seems that this 'he' is changing jobs and even if he becomes a poet and on top of that does something else, too, he may need the case. 2. The relative pronoun 'which' may refer to 'best' - You could say something like 'The men that the country village and the urban housing estate need must be the verb best which can be found.' 'Which' may replace qualifiers 'Which turkey? - The big turkey.' Them = the country village and the urban housing estate both - both of them
11 okt. 2024 09:45
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!