Julia
1) How much milk is in the fridge? 2) How much milk is there in the fridge? Which one is correct according to the grammar? I’ve met both of them, so I’m confused.. #British #English
25 apr. 2023 09:07
Antwoorden · 6
3
The concept here is that of the notion of existence. English user use 'there is / are' to explain the existence of something. In both of your example, we would more readily use 'there' to determine existence. There is milk in the fridge. There are chairs in the room. Use Q words and inversion to from questions: How much milk is there in the fridge. How many chairs are there in the room.
25 april 2023
3
Both can be correct but "is there" is more common. The other expression is likely to sound as if you think milk might be kept in the fridge or also kept somewhere else, and you wonder how much is in the fridge versus elsewhere. You can say "How much milk do you/we have?" if you're wondering if you need to buy milk today.
25 april 2023
2
Both are good and I have no preference for either one. #2 sounds just a little bit more like a question since it contains the questioning phrase "is there?". Both pose a question, of course, but #2 does so more emphatically. Both are grammatical, but the structures are different, and I find it interesting to examine that difference: For #1: subject="milk", verb="is", and the rest consists of adverbial clauses modifying the verb. For #2: subject="there", verb="is", predicate complement="milk" and this difference simply reenforces the fact that #2 sounds more questioning since the core of #2 is "is there milk?", whereas the core of #2 is just "milk is".
25 april 2023
1
Both are absolutely fine
25 april 2023
Also “How many chairs are in the room?” or “How many chairs are there in the room?” ? 🙄
25 april 2023
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!