chen
Why does Gatsby has to die? After Chapter 6, the speed of the story picks up so fast that I quickly finished the book. Just want to thank you who have helped me in the beginning chapters. Otherwise, I probably wouldn't have enjoyed this book nearly as much. I think Gatsby wouldn't have died, if: 1. Daisy didn't propose to go to New York that afternoon. 2. Tom did not take the yellow car and stop for gas at the wilson's garage. 3. Daisy did not ask to drive on the way back to calm her nerves. 4. Myrtle did not run to the yellow car. 5. Deranged Wilson didn't come for his revenge and kill the wrong person. So it seems to me that Fitzgerald purposefully arranged a chain of events so that Gatsby's imminent death is inevitable. Do you think the Great Gatsby would still be a great novel if he somehow escaped his death in the end? Is there a greater message that the author is trying to drive home so that Gatsby has to die? If so, what do you think it is? [I find the ending very ironic, although i can't put words together and explain clearly why.]
Nov 15, 2012 11:52 AM
Answers · 1
1
NoAgenda, Here is my take on the death of Gatsby. There is a chain of events that leads to his death, the last and most important being Gatsby’s decision to take the blame for the accident that killed Myrtle Wilson. Instead of calling the authorities, he sacrifices his reputation and his life to protect Daisy. He knows the police are looking for the car but takes no steps to save himself, even staying home out of concern for Daisy. So in a sense his death was not necessary but a consequence of his own actions. Fitzgerald thought it was important to redeem Gatsby in the eyes of Nick, who, although he hates everything the millionaire stands for, writes at the beginning of the novel “Gatsby turned out all right in the end." and, after learning that Gatsby is protecting Daisy, tells him that he is “worth the whole damn bunch put together.” Fitzgerald accomplishes this redemption by making of Jay Gatsby a tragic hero. He dies in the end for Love of a woman as a tragic knight punished by God for his arrogance. The novel was unpopular when first written because it was thought to be a criticism of American morality, but is popular today as a tragic love story in the American style.
November 16, 2012
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!