YoY
Do you count gerunds? This is very broad question. I am not sure if I understand right. Is verb noun in general countable? If not, could you give me some example and kind explanation? Thank you very much for your help!
3 de ago de 2014 22:51
Respostas · 20
2
Hmm, not really. Just because a word is formed from a verb and an 'ing' doesn't mean that it's a gerund. A word such as 'feeling', for example, can have a plural form - feelings. But if you talk about the feelings which a person has, this isn't a gerund - it's a noun. Compare: You can eat this fat-free ice cream without feeling guilty. = 'feeling' is a verb form here. The gerund doing the job of a noun here, but it is still a verb, so it can't have a plural form. I hope I've understood your question correctly. I have a strange feeling every time I enter this room. = 'feeling' is a noun here. This can be have a plural form.
3 de agosto de 2014
1
As a native speaker, but not a grammarian, I'm puzzled. I can give usage examples but not explain them. I would say that when a word is truly a gerund--manufactured out of a verb by adding "-ing"--then no, it is not countable and does not have a plural form. Or not usually. Skipping, testing, thinking, listening. They have no plurals. But either there are many exceptions, or there are many words ending in "-ing" with a verb-like root that are not gerunds, or there are a lot of gerunds that have gotten a special status as nouns. I can say "he is writing" or "he and she are writing." But I can speak of "Charles Dickens' writings." I can say "He is baking zwieback," or "Zwieback is baked twice, and each of the two bakings is done on a different day." In short, I don't know.
3 de agosto de 2014
1
There are 2 topics here: How can you tell if a word is a gerund? Su.Ki, actually you are not quite right. I would say your example could be considered a special exception along with words like "teaching." "Feeling" can be one of 3 things: 1. gerund 2. progressive 3. noun I'm going to give an example that uses the word "feeling" in all 3 forms: Q: Which one of that guy's actions made you uncomfortable? A: The feeling. He was feeling the underwear, and that gave me an uncomfortable feeling. In this example: gerund: "The feeling" progressive: "feeling the underwear" noun: "uncomfortable feeling" You probably wouldn't ever say that sentence, but it has perfectly valid grammar. Unfortunately, with word ends that end in "ing," you have to look them up in a dictionary. It's kind of like Godan and Ichidan verbs in Japanese. If the verb ends in su, tu, tsu, bu, etc then it's definitely a Godan verb, but if a verb ends in ru you just have to look it up in a dictionary. It's annoying, isn't it! lol Let's assume that you already know that a word is a gerund. Can you count it? The answer is no. You have to convert the verb into some kind of noun first. Example: "listen" If you want to count "listenings" then you have to change "listen" into "a time that listening happened". OK: There were 3 times that you listened to me. Wrong: There were 3 listenings.
4 de agosto de 2014
1
In English, a gerund is just a name for the suffix "ing". It generally connects to verbs together without the need of a connective, like "but". Two good examples would be "I am talking" and "The cars are racing"
4 de agosto de 2014
No, you don't count gerunds because they don't have plural forms. On the other hand, there are some gerunds that have plural forms like: suffering, showing, meaning, finding, building
4 de agosto de 2014
Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?
Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!