minhthi1810
Is this sentence grammatically correct: "After having taken her to the park, I went home." Thank you very much!
12 de mai de 2016 16:41
Respostas · 8
3
I would say more simply, "After taking her to the park, I went home."
12 de maio de 2016
It's grammatically correct, but it's redundant: the time of "having taken" is already after the time of taking, so you are talking about a time after that again, with no reference to the intermediate time. So why not just say "Having taken her ..." or "After I took her ...", or if you like, "After taking her ..."?
12 de maio de 2016
I agree with Stephanie. After having + past participle may be acceptable but it really sounds formal and a bit clumsy. I don't recommend it. The other acceptable option is : "Having taken her, ..."
12 de maio de 2016
I would say "After taking her to the park, I went home" but both are fine.
12 de maio de 2016
It sounds very natural and not too formal to my US native ear.
12 de maio de 2016
Mostrar mais
Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?
Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!