C
Cameron
using 他 vs 別 Sometimes I get confused on which one to use, for instance: If someone invited me to something, and I wanted to say that I was already going with someone else, which would I use?
26 Ara 2010 06:00
Yanıtlar · 12
tetohiko
3
"別”=different "他”=other I'm going with someone else = 他の人と行くことになってるんです。 and 別の人と行くことになってるんです。you can use both 他 and  別. ("他の人と行くことになっています” means "他の人と行きます”.but you have to say "他の人と行くことになっています。this is close to " I'm sorry I'm going with someone else".Of course you can say "申し訳ありませんが、他の人と行くことになっています。” ”他の人” isn't ”他人”. ”別の人”isn't ”別人”
 ...Daha fazla bilgi
26 Aralık 2010
Thanks for the answer, it helped a lot!
26 Aralık 2010 · Cevap ver
[Kullanıcı Silindi]
1
In that case, I would use 他. I'm going with someone else = 他の人と行きます/行くんです (I will add a better explanation of the difference between 他 and 別 if I could find or think of any, now I got confused too.. ごめんなさい)
26 Aralık 2010
Daha fazla göster
[Kullanıcı Silindi]
In many cases, 他 is used over 別, I think. I could think of one example sentence that 別 should be used (and can't be replaced by 他). 1) それとこれとは話(はなし)が別です。 = This and that are (completely) different things/stories. And these are phrases that both 別 and 他 can be used. 3) 別の機会(きかい)に = 他の機会に = some other time 4) 別の日(ひ)に = 他の日に = some other day 5) それとは別に = それの他に = other than that
26 Aralık 2010 · Cevap ver
Thanks for expanding upon your original answer, it really helped!
26 Aralık 2010 · Cevap ver
christina
1
In my opinion,他 means he. 别means the other person. if you want say "please give the book to him",you can say 请把书给他。他is concered above,we all know who is he.But if you want to say"give the book to anybody else" 把书随便给其他人吧。别人means anybody else.Both of them can be used as noun word. In some situation,别人和他人can exchange
27 Aralık 2010
JAPANESE, NOT CHINESE.
27 Aralık 2010 · Cevap ver
Garyee Yue
I was a bit confused at first, cos "他" and "别" have totally different meanings. I guess what you mean "他人" vs "别人". :) In the case you mentioned above, you should use "别人".
26 Aralık 2010
Daha fazla göster
Garyee Yue
lol, sorry. Didn't notice that.
26 Aralık 2010 · Cevap ver
Ha ha ha.
26 Aralık 2010 · Cevap ver
Hâlâ cevap bulamadın mı?
Sorularını yaz ve ana dil konuşanlar sana yardım etsin!
C
Cameron
Dil Becerileri
Çince (Mandarin), İngilizce, Japonca
Öğrenim Dili
Çince (Mandarin), Japonca
Senin için İngilizce Öğretmen
Minenhle Mkhize
4.9
· 76 ders
$5 başlayan ders
Anas
4.9
· 320 ders
$10 başlayan ders
Dammy
5.0
· 1200 ders
$8 başlayan ders
Joel Tayem
5.0
· 1187 ders
$7 başlayan ders
Molebogeng Selina
4.8
· 169 ders
$5 başlayan ders
Thania
4.9
· 604 ders
$8 başlayan ders
Daha fazla öğretmen