Summer
Can anyone help me with the sentence below? By treating their elders well parents send a message to their children that they too would like to be accorded that honor, respect and good treatment in old age. My question is: shouldn’t it have a comma between the words well and parents? So it would be like: by treating their elders well, parents send……
30 oct. 2024 09:20
Réponses · 28
Invité·e
3
Yes, and as a British English speaker, I would also spell honour with the ‘u’
30 oct. 2024 09:30
2
I'd put a comma there yes, I'd also put one after 'respect'.
30 oct. 2024 09:24
You as the author can decide where you want to place the commas or rest pause that your readers should follow. You can even break up the long sentence in two or three smaller sentences. Shorter sentences make it clearer and more obvious as to where to stop and start each passage. 1. By treating their elders well, parents send a message to their children that they too would like to be accorded that honor, respect and good treatment in old age. 2. By treating their elders well parents send a message to their children, that they too would like to be accorded that honor, respect and good treatment in old age. 3. By treating their elders well parents send a message to their children. That they too would like to be accorded that honor, respect and good treatment in old age. (2 SENTENCES) 4. By treating their elders well. Parents send a message to their children that they too would like. To be accorded that honor, respect and good treatment in old age. (3 SENTENCES) 5, 6, 7, 8. It's up to you to direct your readers. Those readers that actuall read punctuation. Yes the first part of your sentence is too long and needs a rest or a comma. Between the words well and parents is a natural place to take a rest in reading.
30 oct. 2024 14:20
Some people will insist it is strictly needed for correct grammar, but I believe it is not. I believe its a stylistic preference. But nearly everyone will agree it improves clarity so is a good idea. The main place I see commas omitted in instances like this, is in legal documents where there are often very long sentences so the use of commas is often reserved for when they're absolutely necessary, so as not to undermine their use in other parts of the sentence.
30 oct. 2024 14:28
Ce contenu enfreint nos lignes directrices de la communauté.
30 oct. 2024 09:57
Afficher plus
Vous n'avez pas encore trouvé vos réponses ?
Écrivez vos questions et profitez de l'aide des locuteurs natifs !