Caxio
Hello native English speakers. Query about real three simple sentences. 1a. The "Bright Young Tings" as these wealthy idlers calle them engaged in midnight treasure hunts. 1b. The "Bright Young Tings" which these wealthy idlers calle them engaged in midnight treasure hunts. 1c. The "Bright Young Tings" who/whom these wealthy idlers called them, engaged in midnight treasure hunts. Query: Which is/are grammatically correct? 2a. Others said it had been indeed a watch-tower as it was still called. 2b. Others said it had been indeed a watch-tower which it was still called. Query: Which is/are grammatically correct? In the 2b, two it's and "as" all refer to the "a watch tower"? 3a. Great character as my father was, he had long since lost touch with his own boyhood.(original) 3b. Though my father was good quality , he had long since forgotten all of what he did in his boyhood.(my guess). Query: Which is grammatically correct? What is the meaning of the original? I guess it is difficult to understand the original (though it is grammatically correct) by the reasonable logic. Does my guess correct according to the original?
2024年11月14日 14:18
回答 · 4
I will assume you mean to say "called", not "calle". 1a & 1b & 1c are all valid. But 1a is more natural & classy. 1b is low-class, juvenile English. 1c is awkward, similar to 1b, but in the case of "whom", is an unclassy speaker trying to appear posh and failing. 2a & 2b are both valid, and have slightly different meanings, but are both complex awkwardly worded sentences, I would move the word "indeed" and I would make use of commas at least once in either of these sentences - but this is not a strict requirement for grammatical validity, it's just an improvement for clarity. Both instances of the word "it" do indeed refer to the watch tower, but "as" and "which" refer to the name of the watch tower, not directly to the watch tower itself. 3a & 3b: Both are valid, but some people will say "was" should be changed to "were" in order to match the tone of the rest of the sentence, especially considering how the word "had" is used here. However, I will not say "was" is invalid - I will only say it's casual/informal (borderline sloppy) but very common form of English; while the use of "were" here is an extremely classy, posh, highly educated way of speaking. The meaning of 3a is as follows... My father had a great character (generally referring to personality traits like integrity and charisma). However, it's been a long time since he could relate to what it was like to be a boy. So your guess is close, but not precise.
2024年11月14日 16:07
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!