Olga
TAKE sb sth or GIVE sb sth Person A is at home, Person B is at school. 1) A takes B some food for him (for B). 2) A gives B some food. Simplest verbs but I got confused. What's the difference? Is 1 correct? Does it imply that A is at the school too (that said, they went to the school together)? When I first saw Sentence 1 I thought it needed correcting. But now I have doubts... There's also an example in the Oxford dictionary: "Should I take my host family a gift?" Does it mean, the person is going to give a gift to their host family? Or accept a gift from their host family? And here we have in Longman: "I have to take Steve the money tonight." Who is the reciever?
2019年3月8日 19:42
回答 · 4
1
The host family receives the gift. Steve receives the money. First topic - take something to somebody "Take something to somebody" is equivalent to "take somebody something." I gave a present to my mother. I gave my mother a present. Second topic - take or bring take has a primary meaning of "to transport" (to a place that is not here) bring has a primary meaning of "to transport" (to here) My son took his lunch box to school in the morning and then he brought it back in the afternoon. In limited situations, to take has the meaning to transport a gift and then give the gift. My brother took a salad to the company picnic (for everyone). My brother took flowers to his girlfriend (for her).
2019年3月8日
1
I suspect the problem is that "take" is used for more than one meaning. take = accept. This may be the source of your confusion. Often has a sense of keeping. take = (accept temporarily and) transport, eg take something to someone. = give, sell, ... same as carry with me and give Here take this. = accept, or, from context keep with you when you go, Take a coat. You may need it. Take his coat with you. He forget his. Take his coat with you and give it to him as soon as you see him. He forget his. Person A is at home, Person B is at school. 1) A takes B some food - pick up, transport, give to B 2) A gives B some food. - give (method not specified) (transport not implied) Is 1 correct? Does it imply that A is at the school too (that said, they went to the school together)? Implies A goes to B, probably at school, for the purpose at least There's also an example in the Oxford dictionary: "Should I take my host family a gift?" Does it mean, the person is going to give a gift to their host family? Or accept a gift from their host family? ==> Give, when you go to them. This is the take = transport to meaning Should I carry with me a gift for them And here we have in Longman: "I have to take Steve the money tonight." = Transport to Steve (implies give it to him) alternative "I have to take the money from Steve tonight. Mother said I had to accept it, even if I don't want to."
2019年3月8日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!