Follow your HEART
You know who/whom to buy this for --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Are both(who/whom) correct above? Does it mean "You know who/whom you buy this for."?
2025年4月6日 08:16
回答 · 4
The grammatically correct answer is "whom". Ignore those WHO tell you it is OK to go ahead and violate the rules because everybody else does it. Doing it right will benefit you in many ways: 1) You will sound educated. The fact that so many people don't know the difference between "who" and "whom" means that few people will notice when you make a mistake. Because of that, and because you are person who is learning English, *PEOPLE WILL NOTICE* when you do it right. It will make a positive impression. You will sound smart. 2) Your meaning will become more clear because "who" and "whom" serve fundamentally different purposes. Those two reasons are important, but not nearly so important as the third one: 3) Trying hard to always make the correct choice will force you to think about grammatical structure as you speak. It will force you to be aware of the role that each word plays in your sentences. Making an unrelenting effort will help you to think logically. You will become a better thinker, not merely a more eloquent speaker. All that said, your sentence was not a very good one even if you choose the correct word. It is a bad example to learn from because it is so poorly worded. I honestly cannot tell you what it means. If was meant to be a question, it needs a question mark and it should start with "do": "Do you know for whom to buy this?" That is a good sentence, but also a rather strange question to ask. Without knowing what the author intended, I can only guess how to reword it. No matter what it means, "whom" is needed because it is the direct object of the preposition "for". Direct objects are always in accusative case. Here's a harder example: "That was a bad thing for ME to say". Me is the correct word, not "I", because it is the object of the preposition "for".
2025年4月6日 23:53
Everyone will say "who" in this sentence. Using "whom" in a sentence like this, is so rare and so fancypants that there's a high chance people will laugh and point fingers etc if you speak like that. I'm not exaggerating. Do not use "whom" here, in casual informal conversation, unless you're trying to be funny. Having said that though, both options are technically valid grammar. Yes, they roughly mean the same as that last sentence - there is a subtle difference but it's unlikely to have an impact on the meaning of the sentence, although there is a small chance it can have a slight impact, depending on context leading up to that sentence being said.
2025年4月6日 11:46
"Does it mean "You know who/whom you buy this for."?" answer: Yes it means that.
2025年4月6日 10:42
Native American English speakers use both in writing and speaking. Correct grammar would be "whom". The way to check which is correct: say "to he", and say "to him". "To he" is incorrect grammar. "To him" is grammatically correct. "him" has an "m", and "whom" has an "m" also. So the answer is "him".
2025年4月6日 10:38
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!